Democrats’ Sweep Sends Religiously Intriguing Figures To Capitol Hill

 

(ANALYSIS) Analysts expected a good election for the Democratic Party. But few could have anticipated a Watergate-level drubbing of the Trumpublicans, with such sweeping geographic reach and wide victory margins in the House, Senate and state legislatures. Democratic governors will now lead states with three-fourths of the nation's population heading into the 2028 elections.

Regarding religion, the SSRS exit poll conducted for seven major news organizations showed a notable even split among Catholics, an important swing vote. They voted 50% Democratic, with a significant slide to 49% voting Republican, compared with the 56% President Donald Trump scored in 2024. Latinos, regardless of religious affiliation, increased their support for Democrats to 64%, up from 56% for Kamala Harris in 2024. Democrats again commanded significant support — 78% — from the 27% of voters with no religious identity.

“Evangelical or born-again” voters went a customary 82% Republican, along with Latter-day Saints, who voted 60% Republican. However, some White evangelicals apparently lost faith in the GOP and simply stayed home, since they constituted only 17% of the 2026 electorate, down from 23% in the 2024 presidential election.

Then there’s the pre-election Pew Research Center poll, which showed White evangelical Protestants as the only religious group giving Trump a positive job approval rating — and by only 58%. White Catholics went from 59% approval at the start of Trump’s second term to 39% currently, while Hispanic Catholics dropped from 31% to 18%. Months from now, we'll get definitive data on religious voting from large-scale surveys by Pew and academics conducting the Cooperative Election Study.

After a campaign drenched in cries of antisemitism and Islamophobia, SSRS says Democrats carried Jewish voters nationwide by 68% and Muslim voters by 86%. In hotly contested Michigan, which elected Abdul El-Sayed as the nation's first Muslim senator, a poll of early voters showed that Jews backed him by 57% but gave the Democratic candidate for governor a commanding 78%.

Some religiously intriguing Democrats are heading to Capitol Hill, and foremost among them is El-Sayed, who suddenly emerges as the Jackie Robinson of America's 4.5 million Muslims. He won the Democratic primary by only 1% but beat his Republican opponent by a comfortable 7%. (Incidentally, the first Jewish senator, elected 181 years ago, was Florida's David Levy Yulee, though he converted to the Episcopal Church. The Catholic pioneer, Charles Carroll of Maryland, served in the very first U.S. Senate).

Prodded by critics, El-Sayed eventually denounced the Muslim Brotherhood but will be the sharpest critic of all things Israel in the new Congress. He opposes Israel's existence as a Jewish state (without mentioning the 57 officially Muslim countries). El-Sayed showed minimal interest in cultivating Jewish friendships and mishandled some interreligious incidents. Nonetheless, he now has a historic opportunity to champion respect between the nation's anxiety-ridden Jewish and Muslim communities and to advocate democracy and human rights in Muslim nations. We'll soon see if he's up to these tasks.

He arrives amid rising alienation from Israel among many Democrats, including Jewish Democrats, over harsh military retaliation against attacks by Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon. This maelstrom faces Chuck Schumer, America's highest-ranking Jewish officeholder, as Senate minority leader and prospective majority leader, and Hakeem Jeffries, the House speaker-in-waiting, who has been relatively supportive of Israel.

This Middle East quagmire plays into the 2028 presidential campaign, which began Nov. 4. Will Democrats rule out strong potential nominees who are Jewish, such as re-elected Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker (who won by 23%), Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro (by 22%), Georgia Sen. Jon Ossoff (by 18%) or the multitalented Rahm Emanuel?

The most astonishing victory was the razor-thin margin won by Mississippi Senate candidate Scott Colom, an appealing Democratic newcomer who becomes the state’s first Black senator since 1881. Colom, who professed his Christian faith on the campaign trail, is a devoted member of the historic Missionary Union Baptist Church in Columbus.

The pastors of two prominent Black congregations will have major voices. Sen. Raphael Warnock, senior pastor of Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, will be joined by House freshman Frederick Haynes III, senior pastor of Friendship-West Baptist Church in Dallas. During his early years in the House, re-elected veteran Emanuel Cleaver served simultaneously as a United Methodist pastor in Kansas City, Missouri.

A Religion News Service headline announced that “The Religious Left Is Back” in a piece that depicted “a striking moment” for liberals who have “long struggled to match the influence and visibility of conservative Christians.”

That largely referred to two victories: Those of United Methodist Church pastor Adam Hamilton, who managed Democrats' first Senate win in Kansas since 1932, and James Talarico, a Presbyterian Church (USA) lay leader and seminary student, who handily took a Texas Senate seat against a seriously flawed Republican.

Hamilton's career makes his electoral feat seem inevitable. In 1990, he and a handful of members launched Church of the Resurrection in a rented funeral parlor. It has since become the nation's largest United Methodist congregation by attendance, with weekend services at nine campuses drawing 25,000 worshippers and a lavish array of fellowship groups and charitable projects.

As Protestant pastors will recognize, that took impressive devotion, energy, intelligence and the building of personal relationships — all during years when the national denomination suffered steady decline. If Hamilton pursues the moderate platform on which he campaigned, he will face energized radicals in the Democrats' ideological conflict. Another campaign theme was bipartisan cooperation, which will be difficult to achieve. The senator could also encourage his increasingly secularized party's candidates to speak respectfully about faith to attract religiously inclined voters who can help produce victories.

Like Hamilton, Talarico showed that liberals can make good use of Bible quotations and face down religiously based brickbats from the Republican right. He gains enormous visibility by leading a Democratic ticket that swept all statewide races, along with many down-ballot offices. The prospect of Talarico-era Texas becoming a blue state alongside California and others gives Republicans nightmares.

Iowa voters rejected two incumbent House Republicans in favor of “mainline” female clergy members, Presbyterian Lindsay James and Lutheran Sarah Trone Garriott. Republican House candidates who survived the Democratic wave included pastor Mark Harris, former president of North Carolina's Southern Baptist body, and Tim Walberg of Michigan, formerly a pastor and Moody Bible Institute executive. RNS noted that the year's numerous "firsts" included House newcomers raised in the Jain religion: Pia Dandiya in Florida and Amish Shah in Arizona.

Advocate.com reported a relatively unnoticed increase in the number of openly LGBTQ+ officeholders. Among them are re-elected governors Maura Healey of Massachusetts and Tina Kotek of Oregon. Maggie Ellis is the new chief justice of the Texas Supreme Court. Chris Pappas of New Hampshire becomes the first openly gay U.S. senator. The Advocate also listed 14 U.S. House members, re-elected or newly elected, in Arizona, Delaware, California, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Michigan, New York, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin.

At the same time, voters in Arizona, Colorado, Nebraska and Washington approved various bans on transgender athletes assigned male at birth competing in women's sports. Colorado also outlawed surgery on minors for transgender-related purposes, and Arizona approved a ban on transgender women using women's bathrooms and locker rooms.


Richard N. Ostling was a longtime religion writer with The Associated Press and with Time magazine, where he produced 23 cover stories, as well as a Time senior correspondent providing field reportage for dozens of major articles. He is a recipient of the Religion News Association's Lifetime Achievement Award. He has interviewed such personalities as Billy Graham, the Dalai Lama, Mother Teresa and Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI); ranking rabbis and Muslim leaders; and authorities on other faiths; as well as numerous ordinary believers. He writes a bi-weekly column for Religion Unplugged.