The Growing Religious Gender Gap Is Really A Political Rift

 

(ANALYSIS) One of the questions that just continues to haunt me is one that I wish I had a better answer to in the data: are young men more or less religious than young women?

I think I’ve written about this at least three or four times over the years. My initial impression, using data from the Cooperative Election Study, was – yes, young men are now clearly more religious than young women. But that’s before I had fully wrapped my head around some of the issues that opt-in surveys have with recruiting young people.

In more recent analysis, I think I am more convinced that the religion gender gap between young men and young women has probably narrowed significantly, if not closed completely. For what it’s worth, Pew’s Religious Landscape survey seems to point in that direction as well, which, by itself, is a pretty big deal.

The fact that women are more religious than men has just been “known” by social scientists studying religion for years. So the fact that we just can’t assume that to be true anymore is certainly noteworthy.

So, consider this another entry into this whole debate but using a different data source. This time it’s FIRE’s annual survey of college students. This one is pretty tailor-made for the task at hand. The sampling frame is well suited to the goal in some ways. I mean, it’s basically all Generation Z (with a few returning adult students), and it’s got a huge sample size (over 68,000).

However, it’s not a perfect data source to definitively resolve this debate. One reason is that it’s not a random sample survey of all young adults. It’s limited to people attending about 450 universities across the United States. So, we can’t really extrapolate these findings to all of Gen Z.

Also, it was an opt-in panel, which means that people voluntarily signed up to take part in the survey. That can be problematic in ways that I have described before. But I think that this exercise is still very much worth the time and I believe that some real illumination can be derived by taking a look at these numbers.

You can read the rest of this post on Substack.


Ryan Burge is an assistant professor of political science at Eastern Illinois University, a pastor in the American Baptist Church and the co-founder and frequent contributor to Religion in Public, a forum for scholars of religion and politics to make their work accessible to a more general audience. His research focuses on the intersection of religiosity and political behavior, especially in the U.S. Follow him on X at @ryanburge.