How Iraq’s Christian Return Model Could Save Nigeria’s Displaced Population: ‘Glad To Go Back’

 

Editor’s note: The names of the two displaced people quoted have been changed at their request out of concern for their safety and that of their families.

LAGOS, Nigeria — When Islamic State fighters swept across Iraq’s Nineveh Plains in August 2014, more than a 100,000 Christians were forced to flee leaving behind towns, trades and land that they’ve lived in for centuries.

Three years later, they began going back. Between 2017 and 2019, Aid to the Church in Need, a Catholic charity, ran a reconstruction program it called “Return to the Roots,” rebuilding homes, churches and schools across nine villages. According to them, more than half of the displaced people returned. The event is remembered as the most successful return of displaced people in recent history.

Now, the same model is being offered as a template for a crisis 3,000 miles away, in the heart of Nigeria’s Middle Belt region.

In August, ACN published an argument that its Iraq program could serve as a model for Nigeria’s Middle Belt, Benue State, where thousands of people, mostly Christian farmers, have been driven off their land by repeated attacks by armed groups for over two decades. Mark von Riedemann, ACN’s Director of Public Affairs and Religious Freedom, said at the time that Nigeria could achieve something comparable if the government worked with the local church structures, alongside international support.

For the Benue people, the proposition landed on a terrain that desperately required it. The International Organization for Migration recorded 464,543 displaced people in Benue as of October 2025, which is the largest number in any state across Nigeria’s northern regions.

State officials and advocacy groups have cited figures several times higher and it is largely without dispute that these camps have existed for more than a generation.

No government presence

Rev. Moses Iorapuu, Director of Information for the Catholic Diocese of Makurdi, said he built one of the first displacement camps himself in 2001 and ran it without any state involvement for seven years.

“For seven years, I ran the camps. There was no government presence,” he said. “Government presence started about 2008 or 2009, but people had lived in the camps for seven years without government presence. And it was the church [that built them].”

Some camps, he added, still operate outside the state system altogether.

“There are some camps that are still run by the church single-handed without government presence. And these ones are known as the unofficial camps,” he added.

Iorapuu was blunt about what he believes has replaced the displaced people in their ancestral homes, and staunch about a return scheme being paramount:

“You allow the foreigners to occupy the homes. It's a question of what? Changing the demographics,” he added.

That position — a return scheme rather than a resettlement elsewhere — is the same one that the ACN advanced in Iraq, and it is why the Nineveh comparison has taken hold among Nigerian church leaders. The diocese and the charity are in contact.

Iorapuu said the two are planning a pilot scheme to rebuild and return one community as a test. However, despite the Church’s position on a return scheme mirroring that of the Nineveh Plains program, its practicality remains to be seen. For one, the displaced population, weathered by hard, long years away from their ancestral homes, has become far more ambivalent.  

A man identified only as Terhemba, who fled his village eight years ago, told Religion Unplugged he was among the first group driven out of his village in Guma. He first took refuge in Makurdi town, near Barracks Road, until the site was judged too congested for the numbers arriving. Later, government administrations moved the population out of the town altogether, to the camp where he now lives.

The camp opened with thousands of families and has since emptied by roughly half, according to Terhemba’s account, as people left to look for land they could farm.

A United Nations agency funds one clinic on the site, which treats only pregnant women. “We don't have a general hospital,” he said.

And the solitary school there — an informal one — exists only because Terhemba started it and teaches there unpaid.

He rejects the idea that displaced people were reluctant to leave the camps.

“This actually is not true, because we are not seeing any effort,” Terhemba said. “I don't have a house in town. I don't have anywhere to go apart from the camp. Where am I going to start? My house was destroyed.”

Then, asked whether people would accept a house and safe land somewhere other than their ancestral village, he answered without qualification.

“Even me, I'm willing to go,” he said. “If you offer a place for me that I can stay with my family, I can go.”

A woman identified only as Mwuese, who was displaced from the same local government area and now in a camp on the outskirts of Makurdi, gave the same answer. She has been displaced for seven years, has two children born since she fled, and delivered both outside a hospital because there was no money for one.

On returning to her ancestral home specifically, her answer was conditional.

“If there will be peace there now, I will go back. I will be glad to go back,” she said.

The only problem was that peace was not guaranteed, especially in the dry season, when the radical herders would bring their cattle to graze on the land again.

“I know people that went back, but once it's dry season, they will come back,” she said. “Once it's dry season, those people will start coming again, like that, like that, continuously. Then people will run out of the village.”

Asked about what she would do if resettlement was offered elsewhere, she said, “Yes, I will go now. Since I will not be running up and down, I will go.”

Unsafe coping mechanisms

The same ACN report offering Iraq as a template carries the Church's account of what two decades in camps has cost.

Father Remigius Ihyula, a priest of the Diocese of Makurdi, told the charity that “survivors living in camps or host communities have been forced to adopt unsafe coping mechanisms in order to survive, including child labour, prostitution and child marriage,” and that drug use and trafficking had risen.

He cited a school dropout rate above 90 percent, a complete absence of healthcare facilities and no psychosocial support or trauma counselling.

Testimony from the two camps supports much of that. Mwuese’s children, ages five and one, are not in school.

“We go to farm together with them,” she said.

Terhemba described a pattern in which families from the host community ask for camp girls as farm labor.

“Please, I want your daughter to go and help me farm,” he said, describing the request. “Before you know, take advantage like that, come close to her, and before you know, they say marriage.”

He said girls in his camp are married at 12 and 13. By his own count, there are around 1,335 children there and 23 young mothers, aged roughly 14 and 15. He attributed it to the imbalance between camp residents and their hosts.

“Because we are now IDPs. We don't have anywhere to go. We don't have food,” he added.

Meanwhile, the displaced persons’ acceptance of a resettlement plan that did not include restoration to the lands they fled from did not change Iorapuu’s position. His view was that the hardship of living in IDP camps had left them with no capacity to choose.

“They have been reduced to nothing because they're poor and they have no one to talk on their behalf except the church,” he said. “So the government has kept them in such poor condition so that whatever you offer them, they will go, they will take.”

“We are asking a question because we need to speak for them,” he added.

Asked whether ACN's Iraq model had ever been discussed concretely with the diocese, Iorapuu said the charity has a direct relationship with Makurdi and that a test case is already planned.

“There is a plan also to start some kind of a pilot program where the people will be resettled, rebuilt and moved back to their ancestral home, to see what we are able to do,” he said.

But he put the precondition on security rather than reconstruction.

“Remove the existential threat that removed the people, expelled them in the first place. This is what we are seeking from the government,” he added.

He described ACN's principal value to the diocese as leverage rather than funding.

“All we're asking is to put pressure on the government,” he said, adding that the charity has kept the diocese's case audible internationally. “It's through them that the diocese is able to get connected around the world.”

For most of the time Terhemba and Mwuese have been in a camp, Nigeria had no enforceable law governing their position, but that changed six months ago.

In March, Nigeria’s President, Bola Tinubu, signed an act giving effect to the African Union's Kampala Convention, the first binding regional treaty on internal displacement, which Nigeria had ratified in 2012 but never written into domestic law

The act was sponsored by Deputy Speaker Benjamin Kalu and passed by both chambers. It sets out a legal framework to prevent and resolve displacement, defines the responsibilities of government agencies and non-state actors, and commits the state to durable solutions. UNHCR called the assent a transformative achievement. However, none of this has reached Guma, Gwer West, or the rest of Makurdi. Kalu said in March that the Act would still need to be adopted at the state level to be implemented.

“Domestication will not end at the federal level. We are setting up mechanisms to ensure that the states domesticate this convention in their respective codified laws,” he said in March after receiving a delegation of the International Committee of the Red Cross in Nigeria.

Regardless, the question of land ownership sits outside it. Under the Land Use Act of 1978, all land vests in the governor. That Act allows the state to revoke land rights and provide compensation, but mentions nothing about families driven off by armed men, and nothing about who decides when others have settled there in the years since.

As for Terhemba, hope has been his only survival strategy.

“This place is just a temporary,” Terhemba said of the camp where he has lived for eight years. In the afternoon, the tent is too hot to sit inside.

At night, he said, it is like sleeping in a fridge.

“If you offer me another place to go and stay, I will go.” he said.

This article is published in collaboration with Egab.


Wisdom Deji-Folutile is a Nigerian news reporter based in Lagos, Nigeria.