Inside Pete Hegseth’s Church: The Pastor Behind The Pentagon Worship Services
WASHINGTON — Brooks Potteiger has known Pete Hegseth since before he became a Cabinet secretary and followed him to the Pentagon.
It is a sleepy Sunday morning in Washington, D.C. The wide streets are sparsely populated with vehicles and pedestrians.
Outside Penn Social, however, police cars with flashing lights and black armored vehicles have taken up positions. The White House is just a few blocks away.
For a few hours on this holy day, the venue serves as the home of one of the most controversial congregations in the United States.
A key reason is that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and his family regularly attend Christ Church DC. They are here this Sunday, too.
Dagen is permitted to attend but may not photograph or interview the Cabinet secretary, who is of Norwegian descent, or any other participants. A uniformed sharpshooter accompanies Hegseth all the way inside, despite security screening at the entrance.
Solemn hymns ring out from the piano as people arrive. For a Norwegian, the experience creates an immediate sense of temporal confusion: The tune associated with the hymn "Deilig er jorden" ("Fairest Lord Jesus") is set to different lyrics in English.
Families with young children predominate. No retirees are immediately apparent. Most of the approximately 200 attendees are white, though not all.
The children remain throughout the service without causing any notable disturbance.
Traditional liturgy
Worship services at Christ Church DC follow a traditional Presbyterian liturgy, as explained in a handout distributed to the congregation. Worshippers kneel for the confession of sin and stand during the singing, which is powerful and, at times, polyphonic.
“Amen!” they declare loudly in unison after every song.
The pastor points out that this year marks 250 years since the United States declared its independence.
"We are keenly aware of both the rare blessing that our country represents and how fragile this freedom truly is. We see this especially as nations in Europe are being undermined — and even attacked — by malicious actors whom they once welcomed in."
He emphasizes that the American colonists had a biblical basis for breaking free from the English throne because the king had failed to treat them justly. However, the pastor maintains that people have no right to reject the lordship of Jesus — something he believes is happening in American society today.
Warning against anger
The pastor cautions against using worldly methods to advance the kingdom of God.
"God’s peace will not be spread by angry, anxious Christians who take matters into their own hands in the name of Jesus."
He cites 60 million abortions, the "transitioning" of children and uncontrolled immigration — which he claims creates chaos — as issues that should provoke anger.
"It should elicit a response," he says, while warning against "fighting darkness with darkness."
"Only Jesus Christ can set things right. It will not come through anger, nor through elections; it comes through the grace of Jesus, which leads a people to repentance."
While the service is underway, a handful of protesters have gathered across the street. Dagen had been informed of their presence beforehand and was told they appear every Sunday.
"It's a cult, not a congregation!" one of them shouts.
Accusations of Christian nationalism, the oppression of women and child abuse are hurled across the street through megaphones.
Gender, abortion and immigration
The following day, Dagen meets Pastor Brooks Potteiger at a typical American diner at a crossroads in Maryland, about a half-hour drive from the center of the nation's capital.
"We aren't afraid to engage in the culture war. We believe it's wrong for the church to retreat into a 'holy huddle' while the world just spirals downward," says the pastor, seated at a corner table by the window.
The “LGBTQ crusade,” abortion, easy access to divorce and uncontrolled immigration are among the issues he believes he has a responsibility to challenge.
"That is why we have caused a bit of a stir. We are willing to speak prophetically."
Seeking roots
Potteiger grew up in a Southern Baptist congregation. For several years, he was also involved in more contemporary church planting, but eventually felt the need for a more deeply rooted faith. He likens modern evangelical Christianity to IKEA furniture.
“It’s practical and gets the job done, but you can't pass it on to your grandchild.”
He found the answer in the church network of pastor, author and school founder Doug Wilson. Wilson is based in Moscow, a small town in the sparsely populated northwestern state of Idaho.
Pete Hegseth did the same. He was a member of Pilgrim Hill Reformed Fellowship outside Nashville, Tennessee, while Potteiger served as its pastor.
Three months ago, Potteiger moved to a congregation in Washington.
Embracing Christian nationalism
The small Calvinist denomination, the Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, was established in 1998. It now claims more than 160 congregations across the United States, as well as in Europe, Asia and South America.
In recent years, Wilson has become known as a defender of the term "Christian nationalism." He considers it preferable to the other labels applied to him.
In a podcast interview with The New York Times last year, Wilson said his primary concern was for the United States to stop doing things that provoke God's anger. He emphasized that this is first and foremost a matter of Christian conversion but also pointed to specific political changes:
“No more Pride parades, no more drag queen story hours (for children at libraries — this has become a key symbolic issue in the American culture war, editor's note), no more abortion on demand, no more legally recognized same-sex relationships,” he listed.
Wilson also wants to put an end to Muslim minarets.
“What do you mean when you say the United States is a Christian nation?”
“The simplest way to put it is that it's not just a Christian nation, but a Protestant one,” Potteiger says.
He bases this claim on the fact that more than 90% of the nation's founders were Protestants.
“But to be clear: We do not want to force conversion on anyone,” he says.
At the same time, he warns against admitting people who oppose the principles on which the nation was founded.
“We see this in Europe: France is burning, Great Britain is being overwhelmed. Such a policy leads to conflict. You end up losing your country.”
Today, approximately 62% of the U.S. population identifies as Christian in some form, according to the Pew Research Center.
“What do you say to those who argue that you are using political means to achieve theological goals?”
“I don't care what such people say. They are hostile toward Christ,” he replies.
He argues that neutrality is a myth, pointing out that liberals also have a set of values they want to promote.
“It is either Christ or chaos.”
Christian influence
“But what does it mean to avoid using the wrong methods?”
“We must do everything in faith in Christ. Ultimately, He calls us to be faithful,” Potteiger says.
He therefore believes Christians should work, including in the political sphere, to ensure that the United States remains a Christian nation.
“Saying ‘God bless America’ is relatively uncontroversial. But if it comes to taking that to its logical conclusion — well, we aren't going to shy away from that,” the pastor says.
He cites abortion rates, the breakdown of the family and widespread depression as evidence that the country is heading in the wrong direction.
Honored by Hegseth’s presence
“What is it like to have Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in your congregation?”
“I knew him before all this, so we already had a relationship. But it is an honor to be his pastor. And it's surreal,” Potteiger says.
He makes no secret of the fact that Hegseth's presence attracts protesters and, consequently, police protection at the church service every Sunday.
“What challenges do you foresee for him?”
“He bears heavy burdens and makes crucial decisions.”
Hegseth has faced significant criticism, most recently over his desire to broadcast an execution following a terrorism conviction.
“What do you think about this?”
“I am not opposed to public executions, but others must decide whether or not they should be livestreamed. However, it shouldn't be a spectacle.”
Ultimately, the decision was halted by President Donald Trump.
Hegseth has also faced criticism for using religious language when discussing warfare. For instance, this fall he launched the "Send Me" tour, aimed at recruiting new soldiers.
“What is your take on Hegseth using a reference to the call of the prophet Isaiah to recruit for the military?”
“I won't comment on that.”
Participated at the Pentagon
Hegseth has initiated monthly worship services at the Pentagon, the headquarters of the Department of Defense (or, as some call it, the Department of War). Potteiger has participated in these services, as has Doug Wilson.
“At the Pentagon, I expressed gratitude for the moral clarity Trump has brought. It wasn't about him personally; rather, I was referring to the presidential order stating that there are only two genders. I see that as a wonderful blessing.”
“But what do you think about the fact that Trump might, for example, tell a journalist that they are stupid?”
“I don't endorse everything, but I do like that he challenges the media. They often deserve to be mocked. Their intention is rarely to provide clarity.”
“Isn't the president one of the most important role models in the country?”
“I would much prefer a society with greater dignity — including within the media — but I believe he is playing the hand he's been dealt. He exposes the media for the circus that it is.”
Has not given up
“Is America in a better position now than it was 10 years ago?”
“No. I cannot overstate how corrupting I believe the LGBT agenda to be, and how normalizing it is. People react when Trump calls someone stupid, but aren't they upset that Biden is trying to normalize gender dysphoria?” he asks.
At the same time, he does not believe God has given up on the United States.
“What gives you hope?”
“Jesus rose from the dead. If that is true — which it is — then there is nothing but hope. Things may look bleak for a while, but Christ makes all things new. He says that all authority in heaven and on earth has been given to Him. With that conviction and boldness, we are to make disciples of all people.”
This article was originally published in Dagen.
Tore Hjalmar Sævik is a journalist at the Norway-based Christian newspaper Dagen, where he covers religion, culture, and social dynamics, frequently reporting on Christian movements, American Christianity, and faith-based public debates.