‘Politics Feels Like A Holy War’: Can More Faith Help Save American Democracy?

 

Amid President Donald Trump’s controversial leadership and the shock of this month’s midterm blue wave, many Americans are living in a season of asking questions about how their civil servants are going to find ways to work together.

Traditionally, one binding American virtue — across party lines — is that of progress.

From Thomas Edison’s lightbulb to Martin Luther King Jr’s dream, our nation’s heroes are those whose great ideas questioned the way things had been done before and found unconventional ways forward.

So much of the belief in American exceptionalism is built on the backs of men and women who plunged boldly into the future.

Only the courageously confident, like the Wright Brothers, would think fixing bicycles could help you build an airplane. Only the madly curious, like Ben Franklin, would fly a kite in a thunderstorm. Only the doggedly determined, like Neil Armstrong, could have made it to the moon and back.

In a nation defined by the embracing of new ideas, secularism has long been in fashion.

Since our democracy requires compromise and collaboration, perhaps the thinking has been that cooperation with one another might come more naturally if everybody figured out what was best for society based on collective experiences, and not on ancient ideas.

Today, in a national landscape complicated by both secularists and religious zealots, compromise and collaboration are in short supply.

So, whose fault is that? Are we too religious — or not religious enough?


To begin answering that question, Joseph Holmes spoke with Dr. Matthew Kaemingk and Dr. Shadi Hamid on this week’s podcast about their new book “Can Religion Save Democracy?: How More Faith — Not Less — Can Heal Our Public Life.”

Listen to this episode of the Religion Unplugged podcast on Apple, Spotify or YouTube.


Matthew Peterson is Religion Unplugged’s podcast editor and audience development coordinator. He took part in the 2025 European Journalism Institute held in Prague, an annual program co-sponsored by The Media Project.