America’s Founders And The Myth Of A Christian Nation

 

The men who gathered at the Pennsylvania State House in 1787 to hammer out a constitution for a new nation had many urgent concerns: A stable central government, a strong national defense, ensuring individual freedoms (voting itself was limited to White landowners over the age of 21).

Founding a Christian nation, historians said, was probably not high on their list. That’s not to say that some, in what was then an overwhelmingly Christian and Protestant culture, didn’t hope that would be the outcome. 

But the debate over whether America was founded as a Christian nation is a particularly modern one, said Mark Valeri, a professor of religion and politics at Washington University who directs the John C. Danforth Center on Religion and Politics. (Polls, notably one released in 2022 by the Pew Research Center, revealed that a majority of Americans believe the Founders intended it to be).

“It hasn’t been a question until the last ten years,” Valeri added. 

He attributed current government initiatives to assert a Christian founding to a combination of factors, including Trump administration politics and the attraction of American evangelicals to the current President. 

“Was America a Christian nation? You can find some in the Founding generation who argued it was, and some who argued it wasn’t,” said Andrew Porwancher, a professor of legal history at Arizona State University, and author of “The Jewish World of Alexander Hamilton,” in which he argues that evidence suggests Hamilton was raised as a Jew in his Caribbean youth, and a “pronounced residue” of his upbringing in his advocacy for equality for Jewish Americans

Scholars also suggested that, judging solely on the historical record, it’s not always easy to say what some of Founders actually believed (though at least nominally Christian, said Porwancher, Hamilton never actually became a formal member of a church, though his wife did). 

American University constitutional law professor Daniel Dreisbach pointed out that some died too early to serve in a national government, didn’t leave a paper trail, or burned their papers, like the Scottish Presbyterian cleric and Princeton University President John Witherspoon.

Then there were men with outsized personalities (and a big paper trail), like Thomas Jefferson. “It's often said of Jefferson that he very deliberately hid his true motives because he understood how maybe some of his religious beliefs could be politically difficult for him to explain”, said Dreisbach, author of multiple scholarly works, including”Reading the Bible with the Founding Fathers.”

Jefferson, he added, “was hurt by some the exposure of some of his writings.”

On the other hand, John Adams, a Congregationalist who later became a Unitarian, described himself as a “church-going animal.”

Whatever flavor of Protestantism they represented, and whether they were nominally religious or devout, the men met up in what is now Independence Hall were already a remarkably select slice of the American population.

Many, like James Madison and Alexander Hamilton, were relatively young – in their thirties.  Slightly more than half had attended college (though most American men were able to read, only around one percent had attended an American or European university). Eight had signed the Declaration of Independence.

In many ways they were not representative of the national population of the time, which included, of course, enslaved people, indigenous inhabitants, and women.

Beyond the Founders themselves (who had their own fractures on these issues), colonists were split “on the three biggest issues of the day — whether to revolt against Great Britain, slavery, and their relationships with indigenous peoples, and the taking of indigenous land”, said Valeri, addressing Trump administration assertions that colonists had a common understanding of Christianity and shared moral values.

Though scholars may disagree on the role the Founders intended religion to play in the life of the country they helped birth, they do seem to affirm one point — they wanted to avoid violence and coercion.   

Bill of Rights and freedom of religion

Fully ratified by the states in 1791, the First Amendment of the Constitution’s Bill of Rights begins: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Unlike the Declaration of Independence, which uses terms like “Nature’s God” and “Creator” four times, there is no religious language in the Bill of Rights. 

When they did consider the role of religion, say historians, they wanted to avoid the kind of conflict many had observed in recent European history.  

Jefferson, Madison, and many of the more liberal thinkers believed that freedom of conscience took precedence over religious beliefs argued Steven Green, a law professor at Willamette University and author of many books, including The Grand Collaboration: Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and the Invention of American Religious Freedom.

“When they came to writing these things down on paper, there was not a lot of consensus. They used vague terms that more or less allowed people from various perspectives to say, ‘okay, that’s fine with me,’” Green said.

In fact, he added, given the bloodshed of prior centuries, “there was this growing sense that religious establishments were coercive, that they did not actually benefit but harmed religion. “

The rise of evangelicalism during the First Great Awakening earlier in the 18th century also brought a strong belief in “voluntaryism” — the ability to approach faith from an individual perspective, not one mandated by a local clergyman. 

Dreisbach said compromise was one way in which to avoid bloodshed — a concern the predates the American Revolution.

“They are being forced to think about these questions very early in the colonial period, and it kind of comes to a head in the founding period,” Dreisbach said. 

The history of state-endorsed religious establishments both illuminates and complicates the picture of what the Founders intended.  In 1776, most colonies had a favored denominational establishment, which was generally Congregationalist or Anglican (Rhode Island, Pennsylvania and Delaware did not).  Over the next 50 years, most had repealed laws that provided financial and civic benefits to a particular denomination, mandated attendance, or required religious tests for office. 

“That is a watershed in American history,” Green said. “We at least have to give some recognition of the significance of the disestablishment impulse that coincided with the Founding.”

While debating on ratifying the Constitution, North Carolina delegate William Lancaster speculated that given the ban on religious tests, it might be possible for a Catholic or a Muslim to become President.  “But let us remember that we form a government for millions not yet in existence. I have not the art of divination. In the course of four or five hundred years, I do not know how it will work. This is most certain, that Papists may occupy that chair, and Mahometans may take it.”

At least at the federal level, religious pluralism, then a relatively rare phenomenon in America, was enshrined in the Constitution. 

Not surprisingly, scholars rooted in 18th-century history come to different conclusions, not only about how to read the past, but about the role religion should play in civic culture today. 

‘Religion plays a vital role’

In spite of the move towards religious disestablishment among states, said Dreisbach, “I think there remained a strong belief that religion must play a vital role in sustaining republican self-government.” Though that role might be unofficial, he said, “it was religion that must play because they thought it nurtured the kind of civic virtues that facilitate self-government.”

In support of his argument, Dreisbach pointed to then-President George Washington’s farewell address, which included these words “Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, religion and morality are indispensable supports.”

Those who take one side or the other in the debate over whether the founders were trying to create a Christian nation are projecting their own beliefs on the past, suggested Tisa Wenger, a professor of religion and American Studies at Yale University.  Wenger is the author of numerous books, including the recent “Spirits of Empire: How Settler Colonialism Made American Religion.”

“Today we have very different understandings of who should be considered within the body politic, and to whom freedom properly belongs,” said Wenger.  

“There was no consensus on what free speech, freedom of the press, non-establishment, or even free exercise of religion meant,” said Green, who has served as an expert witness on part of the plaintiffs in lawsuits challenging state mandates to display the Ten Commandments in Texas, Louisiana and Arkansas (he expects these challenges to ultimately reach the Supreme Court). “Generally speaking, you really can’t find an original public meaning, and so the way the Supreme Court has been going in the past couple of decades in this area, I think is very ahistorical.”

In trying to outsource to the founding generation a definitive answer to the question of whether America was, or should be, rooted in Christian principles and practices, he added, “we are arguably abandoning our responsibility to take ownership over making America a more perfect union, and doing the hard work of deciding, as a people, what kind of Republic we want to live in.”

As Americans spent the year commemorating the 250th anniversary of the founding, he added a sobering reminder: It’s easy for moderns, from the vantage point of 2026, to look back at a successful launch. 

“But the founders had good reason to think the American experiment might die in its infancy. We have to be wary, as students of the past, of projecting back unto them a confidence about the perpetuity of their experiment in self-government that they did not in fact have,” he added.

At it turns out, they were wrong. Even in the 18th century, the winds of change were starting to blow, with new groups bringing different religious practices, a small but growing group of Catholics, Jewish communities, and immigrants heading to America in hopes of finding religious and civil liberties. These groups, which included the Shakers and the Oneida community, said Valeri, were bringing more than religious diversity – they changed local economies, built roads and bridges, juiced local productivity.  

The tide of cultural change, including the faith landscape, as it turned out, was unstoppable.


Elizabeth Eisenstadt Evans is a freelance writer whose work has appeared in Religion News Service, National Catholic Reporter, Sojourners, Christian Century, The Washington Post and Philadelphia Inquirer.