‘The Chosen’ Season 6 Gives Us A Modern Masterpiece Of Religious Art

 

(REVIEW) It’s amazing to think that “The Chosen” has been with us for more than six years. What started as a short Christmas film that filmmaker Dallas Jenkins made for his church is now an award-winning, multi-season TV show about the life of Jesus. It counts among its fans Hollywood icons such as Whoopi Goldberg, Paul Schrader and Chris Pratt, as well as evangelicals such as Greg Laurie and conservative icons such as Jordan Peterson.

“The Chosen” is personal to me, too, because its existence coincides almost perfectly with my own professional career as a film critic. I started writing film reviews in 2020, and one of my earliest reviews praised the show’s first season. Over time, I’ve watched the series pave the way for the faith-based film industry to become more mainstream and produce far higher-quality work. That has been very gratifying. Now, with Season 6 adapting Jesus’ crucifixion, the series is approaching the level of a modern masterpiece of religious art in film. Certainly, it will be remembered for a long time as the definitive modern portrayal of this story.

Season 6 of “The Chosen” captures the historic events of Jesus’ final day through the lives of those who love him — and those who condemn him. Pharisees call it justice. Romans call it peace. Followers call it murder. But in the face of loneliness and death, Jesus remains resolute in following a plan that has always led to one place: the cross. The Season 6 episodes and “The Chosen: Crucifixion” film follow Jesus through the most consequential day in human history.

“Season 6 was logistically the hardest thing I’ve ever worked on in my life,” said Dallas Jenkins, the series’ creator, executive producer, writer and director. “We take more time with the Crucifixion and the events surrounding it than any project has ever taken, allowing the audience to have a deeply visceral physical, emotional and spiritual experience. We give you not only the what of the execution, but the historical why of humanity’s need for redemption.”

Season 6 began streaming worldwide Nov. 15 on Prime Video with a three-episode premiere, followed by new episodes weekly through Dec. 6, allowing fans around the world to experience these final hours together.

“The Chosen: Crucifixion,” the two-hour theatrical film serving as the season finale, will then be released globally in theaters on March 12, 2027. It’s an ambitious release strategy for a series that has defined itself through unconventional distribution methods, from releasing entire seasons on YouTube to bringing individual episodes and full-length movies to theaters.

This season of “The Chosen” has everything audiences loved about the previous ones. Jonathan Roumie and the rest of the cast remain iconic in their roles. The filmmaking is even more confident this time around, with the cinematography, editing and production design working together to pull us into the experience.

The main challenge this season was always going to be its overwhelming familiarity. Famously, the biblical Gospels spend more time on Jesus’ Passion and death than on any other period of his life. Beyond that, the Passion of Jesus has already been adapted many times for film, most famously in “The Passion of the Christ,” which devoted its entire running time to that period of Jesus’ life. It’s hard to find a new angle on the story without being unfaithful to the original account, something Christians are — rightly — very sensitive about. The least compelling parts of this season are those in which the show recreates familiar events without adding anything new or attempts to recreate moments that have already been done much better elsewhere.

A good example is the scourging of Jesus. Roumie’s interpretation focuses on Jesus’ agony, while Jim Caviezel’s portrayal added a noble defiance that created a powerful contrast with that agony. Another example comes when the show offers its own version of Mary comforting Jesus after his fall, something “The Passion of the Christ” already depicted so iconically. In what I think might be one of the greatest moments ever put on film, that scene is nearly impossible to improve upon.

But far more often, Dallas and his team turn that weakness into a resounding strength. Their secret weapon is that this is the sixth season of a TV show, not a movie. That means they aren’t primarily retelling a familiar story; they’re using that story to pay off six years of character development for Mary, Peter, Judas and everyone else.

The filmmakers treat each episode as the culmination of an entire series’ worth of buildup. And holy heck, do they almost always land. Whether it’s Peter, Judas, Nicodemus or one returning character I can’t discuss, the show treats this season as an eruption of emotions that have been building for six years. It’s glorious.

Key to all these scenes is that the show doesn’t force unearned lessons onto its characters. Particularly since Season 3, Dallas has made a real effort to push the boundaries of how much uncomfortable negative emotion Christian audiences can sit with without needing everything tied up neatly in a bow. This season pushes those boundaries probably further than I’ve ever seen, allowing multiple characters to express and sit with raw agony and regret without any relief. It’s deeply rewarding and cathartic to watch, particularly after having walked through the past several years with these versions of the characters.

But the series doesn’t work only as a payoff to previous seasons. It also stands on its own. More than any other season, this one focuses on the familiar characters from the biblical text and builds its conflict around them. So if you’re familiar with the Gospel accounts, you can experience much of the payoff, too. In that same way, the film feels like a meditation on Jesus’ Passion and suffering, much like “The Passion of the Christ.”

This is one reason I sometimes use some version of the phrase “masterpiece of modern religious art” to describe “The Chosen,” both in reference to the previous season and this one. Historically, one purpose of religious art has been to prompt veneration of God in general and Christ specifically.

Christian films have often tried to do that, but they have relied too heavily on telling audiences what to feel rather than using the art form itself to make them experience it. Film theorists such as André Bazin and filmmakers such as Paul Schrader have argued that films should use the cinematic form itself to make audiences experience God through elements such as camera movement and editing.

“The Chosen” does this in a way so simple that most people overlook it: empathy. Legendary film critic Roger Ebert called film “a machine that creates empathy.” And he had a point. Movies zero in on people’s emotions onscreen, prompting us to mirror those emotions when we connect with them.

“The Chosen” connects us to the characters surrounding Jesus and to Jesus himself. So, through the characters’ experiences of love for Jesus, doubt, failure, guilt and gratitude, we experience those emotions, too. Moreover, if we accept Jesus as God, seeing Roumie’s portrayal of Jesus expressing love for those around him makes us experience God’s love for us. This, more than anything else, probably explains the popularity of this depiction of Jesus.

To this way of experiencing God through film, Season 6 adds another dimension: the spiritual realm. In the Gospels, Jesus refers to the fact that he could call down legions of angels to save him, but he chooses not to. “The Chosen” dramatizes this scene directly, depicting blue-tinted, multiethnic warriors whom no one but Jesus can see, standing with their weapons ready to defend him. But the show also features them throughout the story whenever it wants to reveal what is happening behind the scenes in the spiritual realm.

Reaction to this inclusion has been all over the place. Some love it. Others think it looks silly or is theologically problematic. Depicting the supernatural on film has always been controversial. Cecil B. DeMille, a committed Christian and Hollywood icon during the golden age of film, typically portrayed God and his power through explicit visuals and special effects. This approach was famously criticized by filmmaker Paul Schrader in his book “Transcendental Style in Film,” in which he argued that any depiction of the supernatural diminishes God's transcendence.

I’m a fan of the angel scenes. They’re handled with enough subtlety and evocative transcendence to avoid becoming campy. And I’m a big supporter of Christians being creative whenever their choices aren’t theologically objectionable, particularly in stories like this, where any opportunity to offer a fresh take on a familiar story is valuable. Christian tradition is replete with creative depictions of heavenly beings, from Dante’s “Inferno” to Milton’s “Paradise Lost” to the Sistine Chapel.

The filmmakers also use cinematic techniques to evoke spirituality in a way similar to what Schrader advocates in his book. By cutting back and forth between the supernatural and material worlds, the show uses the cinematic technique of montage to create what Schrader calls “disparity.” Through disparity, audiences experience profound emotions through characters that nothing in their material world can explain. This pushes audiences toward explaining those emotions through the nonmaterial world.

“The Chosen” does something close to this by constantly cutting back and forth between the material and supernatural worlds, emotionally evoking the idea that the reality we experience now is not all there is. It’s more blunt than what Schrader prefers, but it’s also more concrete and equally valid. It also reflects the actual evangelical experience of God: through theology and community and, increasingly, in charismatic evangelicalism — one of the fastest-growing forms of Christianity — through an embrace of the supernatural all around us.

“The Chosen” is easily the most hyped faith-based project of the past 20 years. And it lives up to the hype. For those curious about how modern Christians express their spirituality through film today, “The Chosen” is the place to look. For those of us who have loved faith and film our whole lives, it feels like a long time coming.

“The Chosen” Season 6 airs weekly through Dec. 6. “The Chosen: Crucifixion” releases worldwide in theaters on March 12, 2027.


Joseph Holmes is an award-nominated filmmaker and culture critic living in New York. He is co-host of the podcast “The Overthinkers” and its companion website theoverthinkersjournal.world, where he discusses art, culture and faith with his fellow overthinkers. His other work and contact info can be found at josephholmesstudios.com.