‘God With Us’: A Promising Nativity Reimagining That Loses Its Way

 

(REVIEW) Contemporary reimaginings of biblical stories are common, and for good reason, whether that’s 1973’s “Godspell,” 2005’s “The Gospel,” Angel Studios’ “Testament” or Tyler Perry’s “Ruth & Boaz.” They allow writers and audiences to draw explicit connections between the stories of the Bible and the concerns of modern audiences. Of course, these projects are often hit-or-miss, with some biblical stories proving easier to adapt to modern times than others.

Sadly, “God With Us” falls more into the miss than the hit category. While there are some clever ideas and the concept has plenty of potential, the film is too didactic and lacks the tonal cohesion necessary to make for a satisfying or edifying experience.

A modern-day parable, “God With Us” follows inner-city childhood sweethearts Mary Anne Thomas and Joseph “Junie” Love as they embark on a divine mission: to give birth to the promised Son of God in a world set on discrediting and persecuting God’s people — by any means necessary. “God With Us” stars Aspen Kennedy (“The Forge”) and Ashley Olivia Fisher (“Average Joe”). The main cast also includes Rotimi (“Coming to America”), Roger Guenveur Smith (“Do the Right Thing”), Ashley Rios (“Cross”), Gregory Alan Williams (“Remember the Titans”), Clifton Powell (“Ray”) and Lil Rel Howery (“Get Out”). “God With Us” is the sophomore feature from director Jimmy Jenkins (“Sinners Wanted”), who also wrote the film.

This giving season, we invite you to join our mission. Any tax-deductible donation made now through Dec. 31 will be matched (up to $15,000) thanks to the generous support from the Institute for Nonprofit News and The Media Project’s board.

There are a lot of good ideas in the movie. Taking the Nativity story and turning it into a romantic drama with shades of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” set in the inner city, is a solid concept. And the film is often at its strongest when it leans into its more grounded elements. Junie and Mary Anne’s struggles with school, along with their hopes and dreams for the future in an environment where everyone has strong opinions about what’s possible, resonate. When God changes both their lives and their loved ones reject them, it feels real and hurtful. The dialogue in these moments has a ring of authenticity, as though it’s sharing something truthful rather than trying to shove something down our throats.

But the film wants to be too many things, and most of them it can't do well. It wants to be a dystopian political conspiracy about shadowy, quasi-governmental organizations trying to take down God’s people. It wants to be an apologetic for the Christian faith. It wants to be a Christmas comedy, complete with an “It’s a Wonderful Life”-style angel. It wants to be a touching story about inner-city love and perseverance. But it can't pull off most of these elements very well. The conspiracy material is basic and barely explored beyond plot convenience and atmosphere. The scenes in which characters argue back and forth about the evidence for God are heavy-handed and underdeveloped. And worst of all, the jokes aren't funny at all.

What the film does best is transform the Nativity story into a grounded inner-city romance. But it is so distracted by its other plot threads that it can't really lean into those elements enough to make them pay off in a satisfying way.

There are also aspects of the story that become genuinely uncomfortable. For example, Mary Anne says “no” to having God's child before being told, essentially, that it's happening whether she wants it to or not. There are a couple of problems with this. First, that's not what happens in the biblical story. And that's actually pretty significant for a whole host of theological reasons. But it's also important because the alternative — that God is getting Mary pregnant without her consent — is pretty darn gross. There are plenty of uncomfortable things in the Bible that Christians have to wrestle with. But given that this isn't one of them, why create problems where none exist?

The film, of course, opens with a disclaimer: “This film offers a modern parable of the birth of Jesus Christ set in a world where the Savior has not yet come. This is not intended as a prophetic statement or rewrite of the Bible. Christ's work remains sufficient.” This is a wise note, as Christian audiences' understandable “heresy meter” can sometimes get in the way of experiencing a work of art creatively.

But the film still could have felt a little more real as an alternative history. A world where Jesus never came 2,000 years ago would look very different from the one we have now. Granted, I don't think I want to sit through a lecture on where our timelines branched off. But it's important for the people writing the story to have a clear idea of what those differences are so the world feels confidently lived-in. “Kaos,” for example, explored a modern-day world that still believed in the Greek gods, and you can see the cultural ramifications, with human sacrifice normalized. Perhaps that's nitpicking. But it felt like the film was constantly dodging around its alternate history in ways that became distracting as I watched.

“God With Us” has some good ideas that could have provided a creative way of telling a familiar story so audiences could see it with fresh eyes. If it had stuck to what it did well rather than trying to do too much, the results could have been a modest — but still effective — work of Christmas magic.

“God With Us” is playing now in select theaters.


Joseph Holmes is an award-nominated filmmaker and culture critic living in New York. He is co-host of the podcast “The Overthinkers” and its companion website theoverthinkersjournal.world, where he discusses art, culture and faith with his fellow overthinkers. His other work and contact info can be found at josephholmesstudios.com.