Concrete Over Ashes: Modi’s Manipur Visit Ignores Demands For Justice
(ANALYSIS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Manipur on Sept. 13, more than 28 months after the outbreak of violence, offered development schemes worth over 73 billion rupees ($8.2 million).
What he did not offer was the one thing most needed in the state. Justice. This reveals the an unwillingness to confront the failures of governance that enabled the violence in the first place.
The Prime Minister was in Churachandpur district to lay the foundation stone for various infrastructure projects, according to the Financial Express. These included the Manipur Urban Roads, drainage and asset management initiative, five National Highway projects, the Manipur Infotech Development (MIND) project, and Working Women Hostels at nine locations. But this show of economic intent glosses over the unresolved trauma of a conflict that displaced tens of thousands, razed thousands of homes, and left at least 258 people dead.
READ: On A Mission To Help Christians In India’s War-Torn Manipur
The state is still struggling to come to terms with the damage. The violence was not spontaneous. It was allowed to spread with alarming impunity. Evidence continues to surface suggesting bias and complicity on the part of the previous government led by Biren Singh and security apparatus. Yet the political message being sent now is one of economic recovery without moral reckoning.
Justice cannot be replaced by roads and hostels. The violence in Manipur — a religious conflict Religion Unplugged has covered extensively in recent years — was not a clash between two aggrieved groups, but the targeting of the Kuki-Zo minority by extremist groups from the majority Meitei community, allegedly backed by the state government. Ignoring the killings and rape that took place sends a message to future perpetrators that organized violence with political support can be excused or even rewarded.
Compounding the crisis is the state’s apparent leniency toward groups like Arambai Tenggol, an armed Meitei outfit accused of attacking the Kuki-Zo community. In February, the group placed conditions before the Manipur governor on its willingness to disarm, treating the surrender of arms as a negotiation rather than an obligation.
This should have raised alarm at the time, especially since the same group had allegedly assaulted elected legislators just months earlier for refusing to follow its demands. One MLA required hospitalisation, and at least two others were roughed up.
A case has also been registered with the National Investigation Agency against the group for attacking police personnel. Yet, there is no public word from the government acknowledging the group’s alleged role, let alone committing to prosecution.
Without justice, presenting the absence of violence after widespread brutality as peace is merely the staging of normalcy. Peace built on silence and forgetting is fragile. In a deeply polarised state like Manipur, where communities still live in fear and mistrust, such peace is unlikely to endure.
More troubling is the signal sent to the rest of India. If mass violence involving murder, arson and sexual assault can go unpunished in one state, why not elsewhere? If alleged perpetrators can dictate terms to constitutional authorities, why would others not try the same? The rule of law cannot be compartmentalized. Its erosion in one place affects confidence everywhere.
The prime minister’s visit could have been a turning point. It could have come with an apology or a call for accountability. At the very least, it could have acknowledged the pain of thousands still living with the fact that no one has been held accountable for their suffering. Instead, it offered projects and progress, asking people to move on without confronting the past.
Justice is not optional in a democracy. Infrastructure is important, but it cannot plaster over impunity. Without justice, Manipur’s wounds will fester, and no amount of concrete or fiber-optic cable will restore the social fabric torn apart by this violence.
This article has been published in partnership with Newsreel Asia.
Vishal Arora is an independent journalist based in New Delhi, India, who covers Asia and beyond. He serves as editor of @Newsreel_Asia and is a board member of The Media Project. He’s written for many outlets including The Wall Street Journal, The Diplomat and The Caravan.