World Cup In Qatar Will Feature A Clash Of Soccer Styles And Islamic beliefs

Religion Unplugged believes in a diversity of well-reasoned and well-researched opinions. This piece reflects the views of the author and does not necessarily represent those of Religion Unplugged, its staff and contributors.

(OPINION) The World Cup in Qatar kicks off in less than a week. It is likely to be the most controversial soccer tournament in FIFA’s history, something that has dogged the host nation since being awarded the tournament in 2010.

The controversy is largely tied to the Muslim country’s beliefs and mores. It’s about human rights, welcoming LGBTQ fans, drinking alcohol and modest dress. It’s as much a cultural and societal issue as it is a sporting one. It is also, of course, a religion-news story. The focus of the news coverage so far has been around what could happen off the field as much as on it.

Qatari officials have labeled much of the negative coverage either racist or Islamophobic. Either way, this could be the first global sporting event in history where religion, and understanding it, will be a major part of the overall context of this competition. Even the World Cup’s official mascot is an homage to Islamic garb.  And did you notice the gay pride logo for the U.S.’ kit? Apparently it won’t be used during games but will be part of the team’s base camp decor and practice jerseys.

READ: Fox Sports’ Chris Broussard Uses Hoops And Christianity To Address Needs Of Young Men

I explore many of these themes and issues in my new book on the history of the World Cup. With over a billion followers, Islam is the second-largest religion in the world after Christianity. Muslims are forbidden from drinking alcohol since the Prophet Muhammad — to whom Muslims believe the word of God was revealed in the Quran — spoke against it. This is key for sports editors and journalists to understand when it comes to Qatar 2022 coverage.  

For example, Qatari officials have said beer will be sold inside the venues and drinking will be allowed inside designated areas, such as fan zones, hotels and restaurants. I was asked that very question months ago when I was booking my trip to Doha. At the same time, billboards have been put up across the country with quotes from the Prophet Muhammad.

The Associated Press, with bureaus across the globe, put together a great explainer under the headline, “Islam in Qatar explained ahead of FIFA World Cup.” This is a must read for editors and reporters as well as fans and visitors. Here is how it opens:

Qatar is a Muslim nation, with laws, customs and practices rooted in Islam. The country is neither as liberal as Dubai in the United Arab Emirates nor as conservative as parts of Saudi Arabia. Most of its citizens are Sunni Muslim.

Qatar’s most powerful clan originates from the Arabian Peninsula’s landlocked interior, where the Wahhabi ideology was born. Its national mosque is named after the 18th century religious figure, Mohammed Ibn Abdul-Wahhab, who spurred the ultraconservative interpretation of Sunni Islam known as Wahhabism.

Visitors to this mosque and others in Qatar are asked to dress conservatively, with men covering their knees and women preferably donning loose-flowing robes known as abayas and headscarves.

Unlike Saudi Arabia, where adherence to Wahhabism led to strict segregation of unmarried men and women, banned women from driving and kept concerts, cinemas and even yoga off-limits for decades, Qatar has long sponsored the arts, allowed women to participate in high levels of governance and encouraged tourists to feel at ease in the country. It also permits the sale of alcohol in licensed hotels and bars.

While basic explainer journalism has gone a long way in trying to help readers understand Qatar, this just isn’t enough. There needs to be more context with the help of Islamic sacred texts and quotes from scholars and imams. There has been little to no English-language journalism featuring this type of basic religion-beat reporting.  

This omission has led to Qatari government officials having to describe to everyone what their country will or will not do. It automatically puts them on defense, often filling a reaction quote — often drawn from an online information website — in a news story or feature that’s already been written. The quote is just something to put toward the bottom to present “the other side.”

An estimated 1.5 million international visitors are expected to travel to Qatar for the 32-nation tournament, although many LGBTQ fans say they are not going to make the trip. That’s an important story that has been well covered. The other story that hasn’t is what Qataris think of the World Cup coming to them. Are they willing to welcome the world? We know that the officials say they are. Are Muslims split on such social issues? I have to think they are — but that story hasn’t been reported on as of yet. In a second explainer, AP — under the headline “Traveling to, around Qatar during FIFA World Cup” — focused on how to get around and what to see. This section stuck out:

Outside of the tournament, Doha has several cultural sites to visit. Qatar’s Museum of Islamic Art offers both interesting views inside its galleries and a view outside of the city’s skyline. Nearby is Doha’s Souq Waqif, which has traditional storefronts and gifts for sale — including even a falcon section. The National Museum of Qatar, designed by French architect Jean Nouvel, is a take on the desert rose. Qatar’s National Library also is renowned for its design. Doha’s Mall of Qatar has some 500,000 square meters (5.3 million square feet) for shopping. There are also beachfront resorts and tour companies offer trips into Qatar’s desert expanses as well.

It's clear that Islam, its beliefs and culture will be a major part of this World Cup. These explainers are of use to readers and fans as they will be to travelers – specifically the thousands of journalists from around the globe – who will descend on Qatar to file stories over the course of the 29-day competition.

Much of the coverage has been critical. Much of that comes from the fact that Qatar was given the World Cup by FIFA at a time when the soccer’s world organizing body was rife with corruption. Coupled with the Middle East’s clash of Western mores and a misunderstanding of religion that has created a unique set of circumstances never before seen ahead of such a massive sporting event.

I wrote a piece about this at ReligionUnplugged.com back in December 2021, 11 months ahead of the tournament, that pinpointed the following:

Qatar has come under fire over the past few years in the lead up to the 2022 World Cup primarily for its abuse of migrant workers used to build the stadiums that will be used throughout the month-long competition. Beyond that, the biggest issue remains what to do about drinking and LGBTQ rights. Homosexuality, for example, is punishable by flogging and imprisonment.    

Australia’s Josh Cavallo, a defender who came out as gay in October, said he would be afraid to play at the World Cup in Qatar because of the Gulf nation’s ban on homosexuality. Qatari officials have said they would be open to fans of all sexual orientations but expect them to respect norms that frown upon public expressions of affection.  

Not everyone in the Islamic world has expressed such openness. For example, retired Egyptian soccer star Mohamed Aboutrika said homosexuality is “not compatible with Islam.”

“Our role is to stand up to this phenomenon, homosexuality, because it’s a dangerous ideology,” he added, “and it’s becoming nasty and people are not ashamed of it anymore.”   

Among the many issues, conflicts surrounding sexuality will almost certainly be, for most journalists, the most important. While we expect many players from Western nations to speak out against Qatar, what about those from countries in South America, Asia or Africa where mores may be more aligned with the Gulf state? I think of Brazil, a team loaded with practicing Catholics and evangelicals. What about Iran, a nation that is a Muslim theocracy where a recent hijab controversy that involved the death of a young woman spilled over to their soccer team?

What about teams from the West where players are open to discuss their opinions on one side or the other? It could be just as complicated, and journalists need to be prepared for that story. The World Cup comes at a time when a former Greek soccer player was recently sentenced to prison for criticizing a gender identity law in his social media posts.

Again, can this happen as a result of what a player says or does during the World Cup?

The important story from Greece received very little attention in the English-speaking press, relegated primarily to conservative media such as the Christian Broadcasting Network and Breitbart. This is how CBN reported the story:

The Times, a Greek media outlet, reports that in addition to prison time, the Single-Member Misdemeanor Court of Athens also gave former soccer player Vasilis Tsiartas, a suspended 5,000 euro fine for his online comments made in 2017.

Before the gender identity law was passed in 2017, Tsiartas wrote on his official Facebook page that he hoped “the first sex changes are carried out on the children of those who ratified this abomination,” according to the outlet.

“Legitimize pedophiles, too, to complete the crimes,” he added.

Then, a few hours later, the soccer legend wrote, “God created Adam and Eve.”

Tsiartas is the first person to be convicted under the Greek law that makes it illegal to incite violence or hatred on the basis of gender identity, The Times reported.

The Transgender Support Association (SYD) described Tsiartas’ conviction as “particularly important for the transgender community.”

At a time when players are active on social media, it is likely that posts that are both for and against Qatar’s laws will make their way to your feeds in the coming days and weeks. FIFA has said it wants teams and players to quash political activism. Here’s how the AP reported that on Nov. 4:

FIFA’s top officials have urged the 32 teams preparing for the most political World Cup in the modern era to focus on the game in Qatar and avoid handing out lessons in morality.

A letter urging teams to “let football take center stage” was sent by FIFA president Gianni Infantino and secretary general Fatma Samoura ahead of intense media focus on coaches and players when World Cup squads are announced next week.

“Please, let’s now focus on the football!” Infantino and Samoura wrote, asking the 32 soccer federations to “not allow football to be dragged into every ideological or political battle that exists.”

Qatar being picked in 2010 as World Cup host sparked scrutiny on its treatment of low-paid migrant workers needed to build projects costing tens of billions of dollars and its laws criminalizing same-sex relationships.

When it comes to LGBTQ issues, however, the issue is more muddled. Since Islam has no central governing body, it is not possible to state clear policies, for example, on same-sex marriages. It’s this very complicated issue that deserves plenty of news coverage. How much of it will spill over into the actual soccer depends on what the players and coaches do. Will we also see conflicts over transgender issues?

In a time of heightened political awareness and social media, it’s the role of journalists to understand religion before they cover the games. The two will be closely intertwined at this World Cup.   

This post originally ran at GetReligion.