đ° Heâs Fired! No, Heâs Not! Behind The Scenes Of The Weekâs Craziest Religion Story đ
Weekend Plug-in đ
Editorâs note: Every Friday, âWeekend Plug-inâ meets readers at the intersection of faith and news. Click to join nearly 10,000 subscribers who get this column delivered straight to their inbox. Got feedback or ideas? Email Bobby Ross Jr.
(ANALYIS) News doesnât happen on a 9-to-5 schedule.
Particularly during the 24/7 era of social media, journalists find themselves on the clock pretty much all the time.
That includes religion reporters such as Christianity Todayâs Kate Shellnutt, Religion News Serviceâs Bob Smietana and The Tennesseanâs Liam Adams.
Shellnutt and her 6-year-old son were in South Carolina visiting her parents Monday night when the Southern Baptist Conventionâs Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission issued a statement announcing the termination of its president, Brent Leatherwood.
News doesnât happen on a 9-to-5 schedule. (Shutterstock photo)
Shellnutt was checking her computer for news tips and watching the Atlanta Braves game with her family when she learned of Leatherwoodâs reported firing.
âIf I were at home, I could look at my husband and just say, âI got breaking news,â and shut the door of my office and just go,â said Shellnutt, CTâs editorial director of news.
âBut I was sitting on the couch,â she explained. âI was like, âI think Iâm going to have to work on this story.â ⌠Itâs like 8:15, and my kid still needs to brush his teeth and do the wind-down routine and read the books and go to bed.â
Despite the unusual circumstances, Shellnutt quickly got to work and filed CTâs breaking news report by 10 p.m., describing Leatherwoodâs sudden job loss as âa historic and unprecedented move by trustee leadership.â
âA brief statement from ERLC gave no reasoning for Leatherwoodâs termination, which came a day after he issued remarks applauding president Joe Bidenâs decision to withdraw from the 2024 presidential race,â Shellnutt wrote.
Kate Shellnutt covers the Southern Baptist Conventionâs annual meeting in Indianapolis in June. (Photo via Twitter)
At home in the Chicago area, Smietana had received a tip from a source that something was brewing in the SBC.
âI was trying to figure out what it was,â the RNS national writer recalled. âI was wondering if someone got indicted. I wondered if someone who pastored a big church had gotten fired or if they had found out something about the fire at the First Baptist Church in Dallas.
âI did not expect this to happen,â he said of the ERLC news.
Smietanaâs quick-hit story offered this context:
The sudden removal came less than 24 hours after Leatherwood praised President Joe Biden's decision to withdraw from the presidential race, publishing a column calling it the "correct" decision for the country. Leatherwood also made a separate statement to The Baptist Press calling Biden's decision "selfless."
âWe should all express our appreciation that President Biden has put the needs of the nation above his personal ambition,â Leatherwood said. âDespite what some partisans will say, to walk away from power is a selfless act â the kind that has become all too rare in our culture.â
Though Leatherwood praised Biden's decision in the column, he was also critical of Vice President Kamala Harris' record and potential presidential run, writing she would be "cause for considerable concern among pro-life advocates and those who hold to a biblical definition of marriage."
Bob Smietana, left, catches up with Bobby Ross Jr. over lunch in the Chicago area in 2022. (Photo by Audrey Jackson)
Meanwhile, Adams helped cover the story from more than 5,000 miles away.
Thatâs right: The Nashville-based religion writer was enjoying his vacation in Sao Paulo, Brazil â or trying to â when the story broke.
âIf you assumed the Baptists canât drive you crazy from the other side of the Equator, think again,â he tweeted, thanking his Tennessean colleagues Melissa Brown and Duane Gang for jumping in to help with the story.
But by the next morning, the story had changed. Completely.
Did I mention that news doesnât happen on a 9-to-5 schedule?
By 8:15 a.m. Tuesday, the ERLC issued a new statement.
The gist of it: Whoops!
The Baptist entity retracted the previous nightâs press release and said its Executive Committee had not acted on Leatherwoodâs employment status. The committeeâs chairman, Kevin Smith, who was responsible for the initial report, resigned.
Shellnutt quickly got to work â yet again â and updated her original report.
âMy parents were, I think, especially confused about what this story was and why it was important,â she told me. âThey donât follow this news. And they were even more confused the next morning when I was like, âOh, Iâm still working on that because the whole thing has reversed.ââ
By late Monday, Smietana had started hearing rumblings that there was more to the story than initially revealed.
So he expected to do more reporting Tuesday.
âI didnât know he would be unfired,â Smietana said with a chuckle. âBut I did know that there was going to be more news to come.â
âA head-scratching turn of eventsâ is how his follow-up report characterized the ERLCâs about-face.
The Tennesseanâs Brown called it a âstunning reversal.â
At The Associated Press, veteran religion reporter Peter Smith boiled down the fast-changing storyline this way:
In under 48 hours, the head of the staunchly conservative public-policy arm of the Southern Baptist Convention rankled fellow Baptists by applauding President Joe Bidenâs âselfless actâ of withdrawing his candidacy for re-election. Then, his agency reported he was fired â and now they have reaffirmed his leadership.
Even the New York Postâs Mark A. Kellner â who recently left his job covering religion for the Washington Times to follow presidential politics for the Big Apple tabloid â couldnât resist reporting on the âBaptist political brawl.â
Down in Brazil, Adams quipped, â(A)fter more SBC madness, I definitely should take some time on the beach.â
Good luck with that, Liam.
Inside The Godbeat
Frank Lockwood, religion editor for the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, was honored this week with the Charlotte Tillar Schexnayder Public Service Award.
The prize recognizes Lockwoodâs exceptional in-depth reporting on a Little Rock churchâs handling of a sex abuse case. As you may recall, Plug-in repeatedly praised Lockwoodâs investigation.
The contest judge praised Frank Lockwoodâs reporting on Immanuel Baptist Church in Little Rock. (Video screenshot)
Lockwood received the much-deserved honor during the 2024 Diamond Journalism Awards. The Arkansas pro chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists sponsors the regional contest, which celebrates journalistic excellence in Arkansas and six neighboring states
I was excited to win the Diamond Award for Religion Journalist of the Year for a portfolio of stories I wrote for The Associated Press, The Christian Chronicle and ReligionUnplugged.com.
The Final Plug
I finally got my ring.
My World Series ring, that is.
A two-hour wait in the Texas sun was a small price to pay to receive a replica championship ring at the Rangersâ game Tuesday night. (ICYMI: Yes, thereâs a faith angle.)
Bobby Ross Jr. shows off his replica World Series championship ring.
Happy Friday, everyone! Enjoy the weekend.
Bobby Ross Jr. writes the Weekend Plug-in column for Religion Unplugged and serves as editor-in-chief of The Christian Chronicle. A former religion writer for The Associated Press and The Oklahoman, Ross has reported from all 50 states and 18 nations. He has covered religion since 1999.