Trump and Biden make pitches to very different Catholic voters

Religion Unplugged believes in a diversity of well-reasoned and well-researched opinions. This piece reflects the views of the author and does not necessarily represent those of Religion Unplugged, its staff and contributors.

(OPINION) During a normal White House race, the Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation Dinner allows the candidates to don formal attire, fire snappy one-liners and make subtle appeals to Catholic voters.

But nothing is normal in 2020. Thus, Joe Biden and President Donald Trump used this year's virtual dinner to preach to Catholic voters in swing states like Ohio, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Florida. The event produced few headlines, coming a mere six hours before Trump announced his positive test for COVID-19.

Saluting Catholic progressive, Biden offered a litany about the pandemic, race, the recession and climate change. He warned that many Americans have lost faith "in one another, in truth, in science and reason."

The current pope, Biden stressed, embraced him during a 2013 White House visit, offering comfort shortly after brain cancer took his son Beau's life.

"Pope Francis took the time to meet with my entire family to help us see the light through the darkness," said Biden. "I live in an amazing country … where an Irish Catholic kid like me from Scranton, Pennsylvania, would one day befriend a Jesuit pope. But that's who we are as a country – where anything is possible when we care for one another, when we look out for one another, when we keep the faith."

While stressing that he is guided "by the tenets of Catholic social doctrine" – helping the "least of these" – Biden didn't mention his vow to codify Roe v. Wade if the Supreme Court overturns that decision or his promise to reinstate policies requiring the Little Sisters of the Poor to cooperate in providing birth control and abortifacients to staff. He didn't mention his decision to officiate at the same-sex wedding of two White House colleagues, an action clashing with church doctrine.

It was logical for Biden to avoid providing fresh ammunition for critics. But the speech, once again, trumpeted his Catholic credentials.

"Joe Biden's choice to run explicitly on the claim that he is a faithful Catholic squarely places on the table his claim to be a faithful Catholic," stressed legal scholar Robert P. George of Princeton University, writing on Facebook. He is a Catholic conservative who has also been a consistent critic of Trump.

“No way out of this, folks," he added. "It's not, or not just, Biden's critics who have raised the issue. It's the Biden campaign. … It's critically important to see that being a faithful Catholic means, and requires, more – much more – than going to mass on Sundays, … carrying a rosary in one's pocket and finding comfort and consolation" in Catholic prayers and rites.

Meanwhile, Trump punched some hot buttons avoided by Biden, while avoiding the president's clashes with Pope Francis on immigration, environmentalism, health care and many other global issues. In blunt business-deal language, he stressed that he had kept his promises to conservative Catholics.

Catholic schools? "My administration is working to advance School Choice. It was my great honor to help the Catholic Church with its schools. They needed hundreds of millions of dollars nationwide, and I got it for them. Nobody else. I got it for them. I hope you remember that on November 3rd."

Help for charities? "We are once again standing with Catholic charities … such as the Little Sisters of the Poor. We've been with them all in the way in this long fight. We are fighting for Catholic adoption agencies and fighting hard."

Opposing abortion? "We are defending the sacred right to life. … Every child, born and unborn, is made in the holy image of God."

Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett? "We will not stand for any attacks against Judge Barrett's faith. Anti-Catholic bigotry has absolutely no place in the United States of America. It predominates in the Democrat party, and we must do something immediately about it, like a Republican win – and let's make it a really big one."

It was that kind of cyber-dinner. At the end, Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York noted an important fact about the hero honored at this event, the Democrat who in 1928 became the first Catholic nominated by a major political party as its presidential candidate.

Both candidates, Dolan said, need to remember "that Al Smith was a happy warrior," but "he was never a sore loser."

Terry Mattingly writes this weekly "On Religion" column for the Universal syndicate. Republished with permission of the author.