Media Freedom Under Attack In Hong Kong As Pro-Democracy Outlets Shut Down

Religion Unplugged believes in a diversity of well-reasoned and well-researched opinions. This piece reflects the views of the author and does not necessarily represent those of Religion Unplugged, its staff and contributors.

(OPINION) Recent years have seen a crackdown on human rights and democracy in Hong Kong. Among others, in 2019, protests across Hong Kong turned violent with law enforcement officials “using some anti-riot measures which are prohibited by international norms and standards” and “firing tear gas canisters into crowded, enclosed areas and directly at individual protesters on multiple occasions, creating a considerable risk of death or serious injury.”

The 2019 protests in Hong Kong were sparked by the then-proposed bill aimed at enabling China to extradite individuals from Hong Kong and try them in mainland China — yet another attack on human rights and democracy in Hong Kong. Despite vocal opposition, the bill became law and has since been used to target many of those opposing it. Over the subsequent months, several of Hong Kong's most prominent pro-democracy campaigners have been convicted of unlawful assembly.

Among those found guilty of organizing an unauthorized protest was Jimmy Lai. Lai, owner of the independent newspaper Apple Daily and pro-democracy activist, was arrested on several occasions and ultimately charged with conspiring and colluding with foreign forces to endanger national security under the controversial national security law. His newspaper, Apple Daily, ultimately closed in June 2021 after the assets of Apple Daily Ltd., Apple Daily Printing Ltd. and AD Internet Ltd. were frozen, the headquarters were raided by police officers and several individuals were arrested. This was just the beginning of attacks on media freedom in Hong Kong.

At the end of December, the world was shocked by yet another attack on media freedom in Hong Kong, with the closure of StandNews, one of the region’s few remaining pro-democracy media outlets. The Hong Kong Police arrested several StandNews journalists and pro-democracy activists Denise Ho and Margaret Ng on the grounds of “conspiracy to publish seditious materials.” Two senior editors were later charged with conspiring to publish seditious material.

In January 2022, another independent news outlet, Zhongxin News (Citizen News), announced that it was to close on Jan. 4, after five years of delivering news to its readers. Their announcement added, “At the centre of a brewing storm, we found ourselves in a critical situation. In the face of a crisis, we must ensure the safety and well-being of everyone who are on board.”

Within a few months, three pro-democracy outlets disappeared from Hong Kong. Nonetheless, Hong Kong authorities have rejected claims of a crackdown and denied targeting the media. In a press conference, Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam commented upon the action against StandNews, stating, “These actions are law enforcement actions. These actions have nothing to do with the so-called suppression of press freedom or suppression of democracy. ...  Journalism is not sedition. But seditious acts and activities and inciting other people through public acts and activities could not be condoned under the guise of news reporting. It should be very clear what is reporting of news and what is seditious acts or activities to undermine national security.”

Even before the recent attacks, media freedom has been under pressure in Hong Kong. In 2021, before the closures of pro-democracy media outlets, Hong Kong was ranked 80th for media freedom in the world. The 2021 World Press Freedom Index named the national security laws as a significant threat. We see this clearly now. More than 100 pro-democracy supporters, including several journalists, have been arrested under the law so far. Many others have fled into exile.

Media freedom is the foundation of democracy and any attack on media freedom damages that foundation, causing the pillars to crumble. As China continues to tighten its grip over Hong Kong, Hong Kong needs media freedom now more than ever.

Ewelina U. Ochab is a legal researcher and human rights advocate, PhD candidate and author of the book “Never Again: Legal Responses to a Broken Promise in the Middle East” and more than 30 UN reports. She works on the topic of persecution of minorities around the world. This piece was re-published from Forbes with permission.